in , ,

Biblical Classification of Animals: Part 2

Torah and pointer cl

[Originally published as the second section of Biological Classification in the Bible: ethnobiology and more]

Considering how people groups speak of and label living creatures:

Ethnobiological Classification

Just as Linnaean taxonomy is organized by levels within its classification system (species, genus, family, etc.), ethnobiological classification is also organized by levels, with Berlin (1992) providing the commonly used ethnobiological rank system today. Every rank within a folk-taxon connects to other taxa within a taxonomic tree (Hunn and Brown 2011).

Advertisement Below:

The folk generic rank is the taxon that people immediately recognize as distinctive (salient) yet general, and which reproduces with others of its type. It may be monotypic or polytypic (incorporating other taxa). The folk generic is the primary taxon used for discussing a given plant or animal (Berlin 1992). ‘Deer,’ ‘chicken,’ ‘cat,’ and ‘dragonfly’ are often used in English conversations as folk generics.

A folk specific rank is always found grouped with other folk specifics within a polytypic folk generic. It often includes a second (often descriptive) word in the name: ‘bald eagle’ and ‘golden eagle’ would be folk specifics within the folk generic ‘eagle’. A relative handful of folk specifics are polytypic, consisting of multiple folk varietal taxa. Most folk varietals are related to domestication or agriculture. If you have a garden, you might plant ‘habanero chili peppers,’ a folk varietal of ‘chili peppers,’ which are a folk specific of the folk generic ‘peppers.’

The unique beginner or kingdom rank is the highest level that incorporates everything in the category. For English speakers, this would include ‘plants’ or ‘animals.’

The lifeform rank broadly encompasses similar folk generic taxa, though based on a small number of characters (Berlin 1992). A lifeform is always polytypic. ‘Birds,’ ‘fish,’ ‘snakes,’ ‘mammals,’ and ‘trees’ are commonly represented at lifeform rank in cultures around the world. A complete catalog of lifeforms should fill out a given people group’s kingdom (whether plant or animal), but there are occasionally folk generics (whether due to morphological anomalies or cultural sensitivities) which are not included in recognized lifeforms. They may be considered to have covert or unnamed lifeform ranks (Berlin 1992).

An intermediate rank is sometimes found between the folk generic and the lifeform (and there may be multiple intermediate levels between those two ranks). An intermediate is sometimes covert, and may only reflect a culture’s recognition that certain taxa go together somehow.

Folk taxon ranks do not correspond perfectly to the Linnaean taxonomic system. Many folk generics correspond to a Linnaean species, but some cultures may recognize and name two plants that occupy the same Linnaean species (splitting), or may not distinguish between two Linnaean species of birds (lumping) (Hunn and Brown 2011). Familiarity, salience, and utility all play a part in determining folk ranking.

Ethnobiological Structure in the Bible

Using an ethnobiological lens, we can better understand the context when plants and animals are mentioned in Scripture (Gray 2019). When we approach the plants and animals of the Bible, we are looking at how an ancient Middle Eastern culture viewed them (which may have changed over time). The Israelites interacted with other people groups (such as the Egyptians in the Old Testament and Greeks and Romans in the New Testament), which would have influenced their folk biology.

Advertisement Below:

What about Genesis 1? No man was present during the Creation Week, so what we know must have come from God. Does this mean ethnozoology doesn’t apply to that passage?

Moses, as primary compiler and editor of Genesis, guided by the inspiration of the Holy Spirit, was not working with recent Hebraic material. DeRemer (2014) and Sarfati (2015) discussed possible sources that Moses may have used, with family documents likely preserved through the Flood on the Ark accounting for the Creation and Adamic narratives.

The internal evidence does not suggest a direct word-for-word translation from pre-Flood and pre-Babel documentation. First, those original documents had to have been translated from a pre-Babel language. (Hebrew was certainly not the pre-Babel language.) That may have occurred long before Moses had access to them.

Second, key elements in the literary structure (including chiastic structures found throughout Genesis, repetition for emphasis, and thematic parallelism) suggest purposeful organization by a single editorial hand (Ouro 2002; Kay 2007; Sarfati 2015). Raised in the Egyptian court, Moses would have been highly educated, certainly able to accurately and skillfully bring the Creation account to life.

And Moses was educated in all the wisdom of the Egyptians… (Acts 7:22)

Moses was compiling Genesis for use by the Israelites, so details were intended to be understood within that culture. The Creation narrative is therefore true and accurate, and also intentional in the ethnobiological framework given.

The closest we find to a traditional unique beginner in the Old Testament would be ‘flesh’ (basar), which includes mankind and all animals.

  • All ‘flesh’ had corrupted their way (Genesis 6:12),
  • only ‘flesh’ with the breath of life is included on the Ark (Genesis 7:15),
  • and all ‘flesh’ that moved on the earth perished in the Flood (Genesis 7:21).

‘Flesh’ is specifically noted to include flying creatures, livestock, and creeping things in Genesis 8:17.

Advertisement Below:

‘Living creatures’ (nephesh hayyāh) is possibly synonymous as a unique beginner. Both ‘flesh’ and ‘living creatures’ are homonyms, so context must determine their usage as a unique beginner. Regarding plant life, an argument has been made (Wenham 1987) that dese in Genesis 1:11 refers to vegetation as a whole, including the terms ‘plants yielding seed’ and ‘fruit trees bearing fruit’ that follow, though it is sometimes viewed as a separate third category.

Wenham (1987) noted that, in favor of the bipartite classification, ‘plants’ and ‘trees’ are noted to be self-propagating, while dese is not. If dese here does refer to all vegetation, the term is also polysemous, referring to ‘grass’ or ‘green herb’ in other parts of the Old Testament.

Far more commonly given are lifeforms, which are often listed in groups. The best-known examples are those given for the Creation Week.

  • On the third day of Creation (Genesis 1:11-12), God created ‘plants/herbs’ (eseb), and ‘trees’ (ets).
  • On the fifth day (Genesis 1:20-21), we are introduced to ‘sea monsters’ (hattanninim haggedolim), aquatic creatures, and ‘flying creatures’ (oph).
  • On the sixth day (Genesis 1:24-25), God makes beasts of the earth, ‘livestock’ (behemah), and every creature that crawls on the earth.

These specific lifeforms are not set in ethnozoological stone. Whitekettle (2001) pointed out that Ancient Israel’s ethnozoological structure developed over the years, though certainly influenced by the Creation account, into different organizational schemes. Still, later authors continued to echo the Genesis categories. Whitekettle (2008) showed that the author of Psalm 50 used an adapted classification to point out that God owned (verses 10–11) the ‘beasts of the forest’, the ‘cattle on a thousand hills’, the ‘birds’, and all that moves in the fields (creeping things).

Intermediate taxa may be given names, or if unnamed, may be recognized through how they are placed on lists (such as in the Dietary Laws). Within the aquatic animals of Leviticus 11, there are creatures that have both fins and scales, and those that do not. Some land animals have hooves, others do not. These would be intermediate categories. Placement in such may relate to locomotion, anatomy, and behavior.

Because specific venomous snakes are given folk-generic names in the Old Testament, ‘snake’ itself is an intermediate taxon. Whitekettle (2002) noted that ‘snake’ moves, after God’s curse, from within the ‘wild land animal’ lifeform in Genesis 3:1 to ‘crawling creatures’ in Deuteronomy 32:24, 33 (or from what Whitekettle called “High Carriage to Low Carriage Land Animals”). Another intermediate (tsippor) refers to birds in general. (See Genesis 7:14, which follows up ‘flying creatures’ with ‘birds’ specifically, entering the Ark.)

When the Bible mentions specific animals, the folk generic is most often used. ‘Lion,’ ‘cattle,’ ‘bear’, ‘eagle’, ‘goat’, and ‘jackal’ are all folk generics. Some folk generics (e.g., ‘lion’) correspond to Linnaean species, while others (e.g., ‘eagle’) do not. Whitekettle (2003) discussed ‘terminal taxa’ (taken from Ralph Bulmer’s ethnozoological scheme, referring to taxa that are not distinguished further by additional sub-ranks), but as Berlin (1992) noted, undifferentiated taxa represent different levels of biological systematics and cultural cognition, so denoting them as such adds little to a discussion.

In most cases, Whitekettle’s ‘terminal taxa’ are better understood as folk generics.

There are few notable examples of folk specifics in the Bible. Though agriculture often leads to folk-specific names, most crops and livestock are given folk-generic names even when closely related. Exodus 9:32, for example, refers to two different domestic species of wheat (possibly common wheat and spelt) that are given distinct folk-generic names. Aharoni (1938) offered a possible folk specific with what he believes should be translated ‘ravens of the river’ in Proverbs 30:17. He suggests this refers to the magpie, also a corvid, which resides on the shores of the Euphrates.

It should also be noted that not all differences qualify as ranks: distinct life stages may be recognized linguistically, but are not separate levels under a folk generic. In Judges 14:5, Samson meets an aggressive ‘young lion’ (kephir arayot), which Strawn (2009) suggested refers to a nomadic sub-adult lion. This would still be considered a lion. Similarly, different life stages of the migratory locust are given distinct names in Joel 1:4 (Aharoni 1938; Simkins 1991), but these would not be considered separate folk specifics.

References

Chad Arment

Written by Chad Arment

Chad Arment (currently of Ohio), has published in the Answers Research Journal, the Journal of Creation, and using his own website. His goal is to explore topics in organismal zoology (living and fossil species) as they relate to the Bible, from a young-earth creationist perspective.

Advertisement Below:

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Advertisement Below:
Advertisement Below:
Are UFOs Demons? GSR video still

Are UFOs Actually Demons? The Genesis Science Report — Season 3, Ep21